Border Collie vs Irish Setter: Choosing the Right Companion for You

Discover the unique qualities and differences between the Border Collie and Irish Setter breeds.

Welcome to our detailed comparison of the Border Collie and Irish Setter. Whether you're considering which breed to welcome into your home or simply curious about their differences, this guide offers an in-depth look at their characteristics, temperaments, and care needs.

Border Collie

Border Collie

Irish Setter

Irish Setter

Comparing Border Collie and Irish Setter: A Detailed Overview

When considering the Border Collie and the Irish Setter, we find unique and intriguing differences and similarities. Both breeds have their distinctive charm and characteristics, making them beloved by many.

The Border Collie stands out with its extremely high energy level, contrasting the Irish Setter's very high energy level.

Both breeds have a moderate shedding level, which is an essential aspect to consider for home cleanliness.

Grooming the Border Collie is moderate, which is not the case with the Irish Setter, needing high grooming.

The Border Collie is excellent to train, which contrasts with the Irish Setter's above average training experience.

Neither the Border Collie nor the Irish Setter are recommended for families with children, requiring more careful consideration for households with young members.

Both breeds are not hypoallergenic, which is an important factor for owners with allergies.

The Border Collie is categorized as a Medium breed, which contrasts with the Irish Setter, a Large breed, highlighting their physical differences.

Both breeds share a similar lifespan, with the Border Collie and Irish Setter typically living around 12-15 years years.

Concluding, the Border Collie and Irish Setter each offer unique qualities and advantages. Your final choice should reflect your personal lifestyle, home environment, and the qualities you value most in a canine companion.

Comparative Overview

Feature Face of Border Collie Border Collie Face of Irish Setter Irish Setter
Size Medium Large
Lifespan 12-15 years 12-15 years
Temperament Intelligent, Energetic, Responsive Energetic, Affectionate, Friendly
Energy Level extremely high very high
Shedding Level moderate moderate
Grooming Needs moderate high
Trainability excellent above average
Good with Children okay okay
Hair Length Medium Long
Hair Type Double Coat Silky
Hypoallergenic not hypoallergenic not hypoallergenic
Food Requirements An active breed like the Border Collie requires a diet rich in protein and carbohydrates to fuel their energy levels. Portion control is important to avoid overfeeding. High-quality diet suitable for active breeds, with a focus on lean protein.


Both the Border Collie and Irish Setter have unique qualities that make them beloved by many. Choosing the right breed depends on your lifestyle, space, and the time you can dedicate to grooming, training, and exercise. Consider all aspects to find the perfect furry companion for your home.